Gandhiji feared volcano may erupt, 4 crore untouchables could destroy Hindustan, and Ambedkar had the will to sacrifice

gandhi mahadev desai

Mahadevbhai Desai with Gandhiji

Controversy surrounding Gandhiji’s views on Varnashram Dharma continue following well-known writer Arundhati Roy’s Mahatma Ayyankali lecture at Kerala University, Trivandrum, on July 17, 2014, where she, for the second time, sharply criticized the Father of Nation for “favouring” the “most brutal social hierarchy in the world known as caste system.” Soon after Roy’s lecture was made public, social activist Nandini Oza in her blog quoted from Gandhiji’s aide Mahadevbhai Desai’s dairy to say how the Mahatma favoured removal untouchability even as maintaining the caste hierarchy (click HERE to read). Oza, in her second post in her blog, has now dug out more quotations from Desai’s diary. We reproduce: Read more of this post

Govt failure to provide individual support to leave manual scavenging will undermine efforts to promote modern sanitation

human rights watchSummary of the Human Rights Watch study, “Cleaning Human Waste: Manual Scavenging, Caste, and Discrimination in India”, based on spot interviews in Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Rajasthan, and Uttar Pradesh:

The practice of manually cleaning excrement from private and public dry toilets and open drains persists in several parts of South Asia. Across much of India, consistent with centuries-old feudal and caste-based custom, women from communities that traditionally worked as “manual scavengers,” still collect human waste on a daily basis, load it into cane baskets or metal troughs, and carry it away on their heads for disposal at the outskirts of the settlement. India’s central government since independence in 1947 has adopted legislative and policy efforts to end manual scavenging. In recent years these include commitments to modernize sanitation so there is no further need for manual disposal of feces, and prohibitions on engaging anyone to do this work.

Read more of this post

Authorities’ subdued response to demand to end manual scavenging in Dudhrej, a small town in Surendranagar district, Gujarat

Evidence of manual scavenging in Dudhrej

Evidence of manual scavenging in Dudhrej

By Natubhai Parmar*

Dudhrej municipality in Surendranagar district of Gujarat is in news for quite some time following strong protests by contract workers against the despicable practice of manual scavenging. Organized under the Safai Kamdar Hakk Rakshak Samiti, which is supported by Navsarjan Trust, Ahmedabad, on August 14, 2014 they took out a rally in Surendraganar against the way the municipal authorities treat them while on work, and are forced to manually clean up human excreta despite the law banning it. Following the rally, the Samiti submitted a list of demands to the district collector, which included end to the contract system and implementation of the law that prohibits manual scavenging. The Samiti received a reply from the chief officer, municipality, to the memorandum. Following is the Samiti’s reaction to the municipal authorities’ reply: Read more of this post

High time SC subplan guidelines are legislated to ensure due share of financial resources reach the schedule castes

dalit budget2By Mahender Jethmalani*

The Scheduled Castes (SCs) are one of the most vulnerable groups and are seen as low castes in the social strata, since the Hindu social order is a caste hierarchical order. Historically, the SCs have been denied access and right to productive resources like land, forests, capital and other community resources. Further, the prevalence of caste based discrimination and the practice of untouchability against the SCs hinder their access to basic minimum facilities like education, health care, drinking water etc, thus weakening their socio-economic prosperity over the period.

Read more of this post

Gandhiji believed in removal of untouchability within the caste system, but was a believer in the caste system itself


Gandhiji interacting with Dalits in his ashram

By Nandini Oza*

Delivering her Mahatma Ayyankali memorial lecture at the Kerala University on July 17, among other things, Arundhati Roy spoke about Gandhiji and his views on  Varnashram  (caste system), and based on this, she asked a few uncomfortable questions (click HERE to read). Many people have also asked me what my stand on the subject is. Though I cannot claim to be a scholar on Gandhian thoughts and work, I can say that I have read Gandhiji’s own writings as well as the writings of his close aides and secretaries like Mahadevbhai Desai, Indulal Yagnik (all in Gujarati). I have come across a few references in Mahadevbhai Desai’s diary which make the views of Gandhiji regarding Varnashram Dharma/the caste system clear. From some of these writings, I can say that there is no ambiguity in Gandhiji’s belief in the Varnashram Dharma (caste system). Gandhiji believed in removal of untouchability within the caste system, but was a believer in the caste system itself.

Read more of this post

The story of Mahatma Gandhi we are taught in school and we are made to believe is a lie and it’s time we faced up to it


Click on the image to watch the video of Arundhati Roy’s speech

Reproduced below is well-known novelist Arundhati Roy’s Mahatma Ayyankali lecture at the Kerala University, Trivandrum, on July 17, where she sought to contrast Ayyankali’s contributions to society to those of a “false” Mahatma, Gandhiji. The speech has gone controversial, with Kerala Assembly speaker G Karthikeyan calling Roy’s views on Gandhiji as hurting “anyone who is born in India”. Meanwhile, the police sought the transcript of her speech and the video. The speech and the video have now been released by Delhi-based anti-caste publishing house Navayana:

My comrades on the dais and friends, I’m a little nervous because I wasn’t expecting that I would have to speak to such a large audience. I told Dr Suresh [Jnaneswaran Director, Mahatma Ayyankali Chair] when I was coming that I’m just going to come and make a few informal remarks. I thought there will be hundred people. Thank you so much for coming. I’m going to try and… please forgive me if I disturb the comfort level here because that is what I do. First of all I’m here not as an academic or a scholar but as a storyteller. We all know that every society needs heroes, and in India we are not short of heroes except that I think the ones we celebrate are mostly the wrong ones.

Read more of this post

Dalit community land of North Gujarat village encroached upon in 2007, but no action despite orders by DGP, home department

Cops "inspecting" land taken away from Dalits, but refuse to file FIR

Cops “inspecting” land taken away from Dalits, but refuse to file FIR

By Sanjay Parmar*

In a classic example official indifference, 23 families of the most backward scheduled caste (SC) community, Nadia, have been waiting to get back the land taken away from them fraudulently about seven years ago. Handed over to them as collective ownership way back in 1952 for cultivation, they were suddenly deprived of their only means of livelihood in June 2007. The land was first encroached upon by two brothers belonging to the non-Dalit castes of Ahmedpura village of Talod taluka, Sabarkantha district. The land was recently “resold” to a Kutchi Patel contractor living about 15 kilomtres away, in Vadagam village.

Read more of this post


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 501 other followers