It costs a kidney to live in Gujarat. Wither the nobler assumptions of growth-led-development?

The poverty stricken families with whom Ahmedabad Mirror talked to

By Persis Ginwalla and Sagar Rabari

The news report  in “Ahmedabad Mirror”, “Selling Kidneys to Feed Mouth”, by Ojas Mehta and Hiren Upadhyay (March 16, 2016)  (click HERE to read) is on the illegal kidney-sale racket which has come to light in village Pandoli of Anand district in Gujarat. Anand district is one of the richest districts of Gujarat with rich irrigated agriculture and a well-developed industrial base. It is the home of the Amul dairy cooperative, the pioneer of the white revolution in India.

As per media reports, the people selling their kidneys are small farmers and agriculture wage labourers, reeling under a debilitating debt-burden. They are resorting to this practice to feed their families, educate their children, get them married or to ‘buy’ healthcare. Why they have to do this in the heartland of economic prosperity is an issue that should worry us. This area is neither drought-affected nor is it ‘backward’. The cascading impoverishment is the outcome of the Gujarat Model of Development, indeed its entire story.

One of the nobler assumptions of market-led-growth and growth-led-development, or so the experts tell us, is that the benefits would ultimately ‘trickle-down’ leading to increased standards of living and improved life prospects. Alas! A once prosperous community – the Patidars – have been reduced to seeking ‘reservations’, the striking Tata Motors workers at its Nano factory in Sanand are reporting exploitative terms of employment and residents of Pandoli village are selling body organs to feed themselves and their families. The agriculturists are impoverished, those graduating from agriculture to industrial jobs are impoverished and an already prosperous community is reporting reduced prospects. Show us the ‘trickle’, they ask.

Where is it trickling, they want to know. Did the promised investments at the Vibrant Gujarat Gobal Investors’ summit (VGGIS) ‘trickle’ down to these people? Did any investments ‘trickle’ down to them? Did the private education or healthcare ‘trickle’ down to them? Did anything ‘trickle’ down at all? Where are the jobs that Vibrant Gujarat summits promise the youth every two years? Which and what kinds of jobs are ‘trickling’ down and what does it pay the workers? Would advocates of ‘trickle down’ (or its variants) like Surjit Bhalla or Tavleen Singh or Subramaniam S. Anklesaria-Aiyar or anyone at all care to answer?

The myth of the “Gujarat model of development” has long been punctured. But the vested interests keep on feeding this bubble in order to keep their investments secure. Indeed, it has boiled down to this level of personal stakes only. These are portents of a gathering storm. Wake up, Madam Chief Minister. Wake up and smell the coffee.


3 thoughts on “It costs a kidney to live in Gujarat. Wither the nobler assumptions of growth-led-development?

  1. This is to notify the general media audience on the sale and buying of vital body organs for a reasonable amount of fund. We’re a registered and licensed organization specialized in operating, buying and selling of organs such as heart, kidney, lung and liver. We guarantee a 100 percent safe procedure, as our surgeons and neurologists are the best in the world and you shall also get access to huge capital which will enable you live a better life. Interested clients should kindly contact via email: ( + mobile (+918904820160, 00918904820160) only. We hope to hear from you, as you shall be treated whole hearten with the best of our medical resources.



  2. Hello,
    I’m looking for kidney donors,Very urgently. B ve ,O ve and A ve with India passports/ Voters card or Pan-card and age should be more than 22 years. Interested people contact me at Email:
    Whatsapp No: +91-7406570913
    Phone No: +91-7406574527
    Dr Raymond Cole


  3. This is due to the general public Male or Female who should be healthy
    and 100% in selling their kidney urgently contact Pyramid Center.As we
    have a lot of patients who are for kidney are Here informed, look for
    a way to get your Kidney for sale money from financial collapse while
    we are offering $ 308,000.00 for your kidneys. My name is Dr.
    Dr. Gregory Solomon, I’m a Nephrologist in Surgrical Hospital. This is Dr.
    Dr. Gregory Solomon Surgrical Hospital in India who are specialist in kidney
    surgery / transplantation and other organ treatment, we also purchase
    and transplantation of kidneys with a living and healthy donor deal.
    If you are interested in selling your kidney, please do not hesitate
    to contact us via email:
    Please note: Internet there are a lot of people with different theme,
    so we are not asking honest and truthful kid, this is not accepted
    about saving the lives of others Fraudulent you.

    Best Regards …
    Dr. Gregory Solomon
    phone +918142270607
    WHATS APP MESSAGE ONLY +918951705282

    Dr. Gregory Solomon Surgrical Hospital


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s