Why stories of child sexual abuse in India such as that from Kathua continue to emerge every day

bachpan6Excerpt from the report, “Children Cannot Wait: Status of Pending Trials in Child Sexual Abuse Cases in India”, prepared by the Kailash Satyarthi Children’s Foundation:

The brutal rape and murder of an eight year old girl in Kathua (Jammu and Kashmir) in January 2018 has shaken the conscience of the nation. The public outcry following this harrowing case is reminiscent of the mass protests against the horrifying gangrape of a young girl in Delhi in December 2012, when justice delivery mechanisms against rape in India were amended to be more stringent and robust.

bachpan2
Approximate No of years needed to complete the trial of pending cases as on 2016
(Based on absolute numbers of pending cases)

Amongst others amendments, Section 375 of the India Penal Code 1980 was expanded to include a wider definition of rape. Section 167 of the Code for Criminal Procedure 1973 states that investigation in cases of child rape to be completed within two months of registration of the cases and Section 309 establishes that trial of cases of rape must be completed within two months, as far as possible.

But stories of child rape and sexual abuse such as that from Kathua continue to emerge every day, in the absence of a responsive justice delivery system. In light of this urgent and growing demand for justice for victims of child rape, the Kailash Satyarthi Children’s Foundation (KSCF) presents a state-wise timeline of pendency of cases of child sexual abuse, as per the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India response to a Lok Sabha question number 2544 (1st August 2017).

bachpan2
Approximate No of years needed to complete the trial of pending cases as on 2016
(Based on case disposal rate). Note: Arunachal Pradesh, Gujarat & Manipur may require more than 200 years to complete trial of pending cases

This is related to the prosecution of cases of crimes of child sexual abuse under the POCSO Act 2012 between 2014 and 2016.

Data analysis the completion of trial is too slow

For any particular year the number of cases registered and the pending cases of the previous year constitutes total number of cases for trial. The percentage of cases in which trials have been completed is a mere one tenth of the total cases under trial. This trend has persisted during 2015-16.

Almost two decades to clear backlogs

Using the information provided to Lok Sabha Unstarred Q. No. 2544 an approximate number of years needed to complete currently pending trials has been calculated.

bachpan4
Percent change in number of pending cases over previous year (2014-16)

This has been calculated at India and State level with the assumption that case disposal rate during 2016 is constant. Due to addition of new cases every year for trial, instead of absolute numbers case disposal rate has been used for this calculation. Figure 2 depicts that India will take about 20 years clear the back log of 2016.

 

At state level it varies from two years in Punjab to more than 60 years in Arunachal Pradesh, Gujarat, Manipur, West Bengal and Kerala.

 

bachpan3
Percent cases completed against total No. of cases on trial in that year
(2015-16)

Pendency on the rise

 

The number of pending cases during 2015 has increased by 37% over 2014 (increased from 52,309 in 2014 to 71,552 in 2015). However, the same during 2016 has increased at 26% (increased from 71,552 in 2015 to 89,999 in 2016). Comparison of trial completion rate, new cases getting registered every year for grail and number of pending cases indicates that numbers presented under column ‘Pending Trial at the end of the year’ in answer to Lok Sabha Unstarred Q. No. 2544 is incorrect/ inconsistent.

bachpan5
Conviction rate under POCSO in last three years

Convictions remain a distant dream

With regard to conviction rate it is evident that conviction under POCSO has remained constant at 30% during 2014-16. However it has registered an increase of 6% during 2015. Figure 4 clearly maps the trend.

Click HERE for full report


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s